CMCRC finds SEC rules favour dark pools

CMCRC finds SEC rules favour dark pools

SEC trading rules may be providing dark venues with a regulatory advantage over traditional stock exchanges, according to a new paper by The Capital Markets Cooperative Research Centre (CMCRC).

Dark pools, by allowing some traders to circumvent market order time priority, create a queue-jumping advantage that has facilitated their rapid growth at the expense of traditonal lit venues.

“Our study found a sharp rise in dark venue market share when stock prices are just above the $1 level,” Amy Kwan, CMCRC PhD said.

“The effect isn’t constrained to penny stocks – high priced stocks exhibit similar behaviours. We also see that on trading days when stocks are severely constrained by the minimum pricing increment, dark venues gain market share as well.”

Limit orders submitted to dark venues can execute ahead of displayed orders on lit exchanges as long as the price is at or within the National Best Bid and Offer (NBBO). This drags liquidity away, reducing depth and increasing spreads on lit markets.

The study looked at market depth, particularly around the $1 price level. Regulation National Market System rules mean that when stock drops below $1, minimum pricing increments fall from $0.01 to $0.0001.

This means there are strong incentives for traders to migrate their order flow to dark venues to benefit from queue jumping when stocks are trading just above $1. This incentive is lost when the price falls below the $1 threshold.

The study lends support to the introduction of a new rule, which would requiring dark orders to be routed to lit exchanges unless dark pools can provide meaningful price improvement would support depth and tighten spreads on the lit markets which in turn is positive for price discovery.