50 Shades of Grey Trading - the future of prop
By Sam Tyfield
At FOW's event 'The
Evolution of Proprietary Trading' on March 4th, there was some lively
discussion about the future of point-and-click trading and other non-automated
trading strategies.
What was clear (and
should be emphasised) is that there exists in the markets:
* Space and opportunities for traders across the entire
spectrum of trading strategies and methodologies; and
* Opportunities for all traders to benefit from
automation in one form or other.
In relation to the first point, the higher frequency strategies can provide benefits to other market participants by warehousing short-term risk over short time periods and the more ‘human’ strategies and participants can warehouse longer-term risk over longer periods or by taking into account different inputs and goals.
There has been a significant amount of discussion on both sides of the Atlantic about making markets ‘safer’ and re-enforcing trust in the secondary markets for retail and institutional investors. There is space therefore for different strategies and different participants with different risk considerations, time horizons, data inputs and execution methodologies. Having access to enormous amounts of data, vast processing capabilities, co-location etc does not necessarily make or break a strategy or prove that one participant with those will (or will not) be successful.
Similarly, not having those will not make a participant successful or unsuccessful. If a participant has a buy-and-hold strategy then (provided that its risk limits are not tripped by price movements during the hold period) strategies or participants with different trading/hold periods should actually be beneficial to that participant when (if) it comes to buy or sell the instruments/products it wants/holds.
Hopefully, there should be space for all types of
traders/investors and all types of strategies. The trick is for each of them to
know against whom they are competing for revenue and ensure that whatever tools
they need to do so, they have. Which leads us to the second point...
One panelist on the ‘Algo Opportunities for Prop Traders’ panel has established recently a prop-trading firm, which, currently, is mainly point-and-click. His intention is to automate much of the processes from order formation to execution, but to do so, he will identify which parts of the order chain should be automated (and how) as the firm and the strategies develop.
He will use tools available as necessary (most bought, rather than built) in order to do so. And who knows, perhaps it will be the case that because the strategies which are running do not need to be ‘HFT’ nor to have infrastructure which is co-located etc, there will remain some or a substantial portion of the order chain which is manual.
The trick is to
identify which processes could benefit him (or free him up to do clever thinky
strategy stuff) by becoming automated. Someone at the event described such
automated processes as like having an “iClerk”; a clerk one does not have to
pay, who does not take lunch breaks, who doesn’t get bored, who won’t take
holidays and who doesn’t get your order wrong at Alfredo’s.
Long-and-short is
that every market participant *should* consider whether any part of his/her
order chain could benefit from automation but not consider that it has to
become HFT or fully automated, unless his/her strategies demand that to be the
case. Viva the Grey Box.
Found this useful?
Take a complimentary trial of the FOW Marketing Intelligence Platform – the comprehensive source of news and analysis across the buy- and sell- side.
Gain access to:
- A single source of in-depth news, insight and analysis across Asset Management, Securities Finance, Custody, Fund Services and Derivatives
- Our interactive database, optimized to enable you to summarise data and build graphs outlining market activity
- Exclusive whitepapers, supplements and industry analysis curated and published by Futures & Options World
- Breaking news, daily and weekly alerts on the markets most relevant to you